question

michael-reed avatar image
michael-reed asked Ray Gay answered

Router, switch, and VLAN questions

Hello,

I am a new customer and I could use some help understanding some things before I implement. Currently the company owns a Netgear GS324TP POE managed switch and a Linksys WRT3200ACM router. We just ordered 8 Polycom VVX phones, so there likely won't be more than 10 simultaneous calls, but I expect the company to grow and therefore I should plan for up to 20 simultaneous calls. I plan on connecting the desktops to the 2nd port on the phones. Other ports on the switch will connect about 7 printers and scanners.

I am led to believe that I should configure VLANS on the switch, one for tagged voip traffic, one for data traffic (desktops and printers) and one for wifi, plus the default VLAN for management.

I can configure the VLANS on the switch, but I'm not sure if the WRT3200ACM router can deal with VLANS. Does anyone have a recommendation for a proper router that I can configure the various DHCP interfaces on to accomodate the VLANS? I'm thinking of the Ubiquiti USG router. I saw an excellent Youtube video by someone that explained his setup pretty well. I'm not an expert with any of this and would be happy to pay an experienced network engineer to help me out by phone. I appreciate any advice you can offer.

hardware
1 |3000

Up to 8 attachments (including images) can be used with a maximum of 1.0 MiB each and 10.0 MiB total.

michael-reed avatar image
michael-reed answered michael-reed commented
Thank you for such a quick reply.  So, having the desktops plugged into port 2 of the phone won't affect the quality?  I was under the impression that if I created separate vlans, I could tag the voice traffic on that port and not tag the other traffic, therefore the voice would get priority on that port.  But if you don''t think that will be a problem, that would simplify things for me.   Next question:  The things you recommended, the traffic shaping and QoS, those are done on the router, the switch, or both?
I will research at your links in the meantime.  Thanks again.
3 comments
1 |3000

Up to 8 attachments (including images) can be used with a maximum of 1.0 MiB each and 10.0 MiB total.

danno147 avatar image danno147 commented ·
There are so many variables that need to be considered in order to provide the best answer.  But the quick answer is this; if you have a single Ethernet connection, back to the network, the phone will be given a unique IP & MAC address and the PC will be given a unique IP & MAC address.  In terms of QoS shaping; only one device and preferably the router/firewall.

0 Likes 0 ·
danno147 avatar image danno147 commented ·
Based on my answer above, I'd say this would be moot so I'm going to take a mulligan on this one.
0 Likes 0 ·
michael-reed avatar image michael-reed commented ·
Thank you. I will research that.  I'm pretty sure mac addresses can be prioritized on that wrt3200acm router.
0 Likes 0 ·
danno147 avatar image
danno147 answered danno147 commented
Michael, I really don't think VLANs are necessary.  I base that on having several clients, as small as 10 phones at a single location to a school system with 100+ phones at four geographic locations, and none of then have a VLAN. Traffic shaping, QoS, Prioritizing traffic (everybody & every manufacturer has a different name for it) is what I recommend you research and apply. 
1 comment
1 |3000

Up to 8 attachments (including images) can be used with a maximum of 1.0 MiB each and 10.0 MiB total.

Ray Gay avatar image
Ray Gay answered

Michael-Reed: Did you ever get clear information on this question? In my experience, small IP phone installation using hosted services (like RingCentral) seem to work OK without VLAN setups. The catch comes when you try to troubleshoot a particular problem. The tech support will start questioning you in general about how your network is set up and if they don't like the answers, you will not get much help. I recently had an installation going from one provider to RingCentral. The phones with the old provider generally worked fine with no special network settings. That provider never came up with network configuration guidelines except to quote the generic QOS/traffic/double-NAT jargon even though we used the network router/firewall that they recommended. We were on our own as to how to implement "good" settings. RingCentral provided thorough guidelines and some general recommendations from the support engineer, like: "phone VLAN, data VLAN, mgmt VLAN" separation. There were warnings about support if I didn't do it "their" way. The RC documents explain every possible way that you could set up your network and let you divine the best way on your own. It is still not clear to me if the phones actually read their VLAN tags in their software or put VLAN tags on outgoing ethernet packets or mark them with Layer 3 data. I found one very good document on the Sonicwall setup for the LAN-to-WAN path that includes DSCP mark-up. The phones boot and provision successfully and there are no obvious issues with voice quality. Beyond that, it looks like regular experimentation and recording of data is necessary to become proficient in my particular network setup. It's obvious that nearly all "engineers" are trained on Cisco gear for these topics but mostly shrug when confronted with questions about specific non-Cisco gear.

1 |3000

Up to 8 attachments (including images) can be used with a maximum of 1.0 MiB each and 10.0 MiB total.

Work together.
From anywhere.

Team messaging, video meetings
and phone - all in one app.


Get the new RingCentral app